A buyer sends the same one-page brief to a sulphate-free shampoo OEM in Guangzhou that they used for a conventional shampoo last year, swaps "SLES" for "sulphate-free," and expects the quote to move by a few cents. Then the sample arrives thin as water, the foam is half what the retail panel expected, the price is up by a margin nobody budgeted, and the factory says the viscosity "needs another round." None of that is a factory problem. It is a brief problem: the two surfactant systems behave differently enough that a brief written for one does not describe the other. This article walks through what actually changes — cost, viscosity, foam, clarity, preservation, compounding and lead time — and what to write into the brief so the first sample is a near-miss rather than a placeholder.
What "sulphate-free" means on a brief, and why the definition matters
The sulphates in question are the alkyl sulphates and alkyl ether sulphates: sodium lauryl sulphate (SLS), sodium laureth sulphate (SLES), ammonium lauryl sulphate (ALS) and ammonium laureth sulphate (ALES). SLES in particular is the workhorse primary surfactant in most conventional shampoo because it is cheap, foams strongly, cleans well and thickens with a few percent of salt.
The trap is that "sulphate-free" is a marketing definition, not a chemical one. Sodium C14-16 olefin sulfonate is a sulfonate, not a sulphate, and passes most brand definitions — but it foams and strips in a way that consumers avoiding harshness may not expect. Sodium coco-sulfate is chemically a sulphate and appears in some "natural" formulas, which makes it a claim risk. If your definition excludes sulfonates, or requires a certification body's ingredient list, that must be on the brief in writing. Otherwise the factory formulates to the chemical definition, which is the only one it can defend.
Write it as an exclusion list, not an adjective: "No SLS, SLES, ALS, ALES, sodium coco-sulfate. Olefin sulfonate: [permitted / not permitted]."
The surfactant swap and what it drags with it
A conventional shampoo is typically built on SLES with cocamidopropyl betaine (CAPB) as the secondary surfactant. A sulphate-free shampoo replaces SLES with one or more of:
- Sodium cocoyl isethionate (SCI) — mild, dense creamy foam, supplied as solid flakes or needles.
- Sodium lauroyl sarcosinate or sodium methyl cocoyl taurate — anionic, good foam, liquid or paste.
- Alkyl polyglucosides (decyl glucoside, coco-glucoside, lauryl glucoside) — nonionic, very mild, poor foam alone, high native pH.
- Sodium lauroyl glutamate, disodium cocoyl glutamate — amino-acid surfactants, mild, expensive.
- Sodium C14-16 olefin sulfonate — strong foam, closer to SLES in performance, if your definition allows it.
None of these is a drop-in for SLES. Each changes the properties around it.
| Property | Conventional (SLES/CAPB) | Sulphate-free (typical) | What to write in the brief |
|---|---|---|---|
| Surfactant raw-material cost | Baseline | Commonly a multiple of the SLES cost on the surfactant portion; overall unit cost effect depends on the rest of the formula | Ask for the formula cost split, not just a unit price |
| Thickening | Salt curve — a few percent NaCl builds viscosity for near-zero cost | Salt does little; needs a polymeric or nonionic thickener (e.g. PEG-120 methyl glucose dioleate, acrylates crosspolymer, cellulose or xanthan systems) | Target viscosity range and the method used to measure it |
| Foam | High volume, fast flash foam | Lower volume, denser, slower to build; glucoside-only systems foam poorly | Foam expectation stated as a test, not a feeling |
| Clarity | Easily water-clear | SCI systems are often opaque or pearlescent unless carefully balanced | Clear / pearl / opaque — pick one |
| pH | Typically adjusted to ~5–6 | Glucosides arrive alkaline and must be brought down; isethionates hydrolyse if pH sits too low or too high | State a pH window on the spec |
| Compounding | Cold-process, fast | SCI often needs heating to dissolve; longer kettle time | Expect the factory to quote batch time separately |
| Preservation | Well-understood | Some sulphate-free systems raise the water activity and nutrient load for microbes; preservative selection may change | Preservative system and challenge test requirement |
| Label claim | "Cleans" | "Sulphate-free" is a claim — you must be able to show the INCI supports it | Full INCI required with the sample |
Three rows in that table are where budgets and timelines get lost.
Cost: where the money actually goes
SLES is one of the lowest-cost surfactants available. Isethionates, sarcosinates, taurates and amino-acid surfactants cost multiples of that per kilo of active matter, and a sulphate-free shampoo frequently needs a higher total surfactant load for comparable cleansing, because the mild surfactants are individually weaker. Add the thickener you now need because salt no longer works, and the surfactant-plus-rheology portion can move from a minor cost line to the dominant one.
What that does to unit price depends on everything else in the bottle. A shampoo where the bottle and pump cost more than the fill sees a modest change; a large-format bulk shampoo where the fill dominates sees a bigger one. Do not accept a single per-unit number. Ask the factory to break the quote into bulk formula, filling and packaging, and to show bulk cost per kilo for both the conventional and sulphate-free versions of the same brief. That comparison tells you whether the factory is charging for chemistry or for novelty.
Also ask whether the surfactant is priced on active matter or as-supplied. SLES is commonly traded at 70% active, CAPB at around 30%, SCI at 80%-plus, and glucosides at 50% or so. A formula listing 12% "surfactant" says nothing until you know the activity.
Viscosity: the round that gets lost
The most common reason a sulphate-free project takes an extra sampling round is viscosity. Salt does nothing, so a thickening system has to be built from scratch — and the thickener interacts with the surfactants, the pH, the fragrance and the temperature. Sulphate-free systems thicken with one or more of:
- Nonionic associative thickeners such as PEG-120 methyl glucose dioleate or PEG-150 pentaerythrityl tetrastearate — effective, but they can dull foam and cloud clarity.
- Acrylates crosspolymers — build a stable, shear-thinning body, but they are pH-sensitive and can feel "gel-like" rather than "shampoo-like."
- Cellulose derivatives, xanthan or sclerotium gum — natural-positioning friendly, but stringy at high levels and slow to hydrate in the kettle.
- Glyceryl oleate, cocamide MIPA, lauryl lactyl lactate and similar co-surfactants — used as much for body as for foam.
Each changes how the product leaves a pump or squeeze bottle, and each drifts differently after filling. Viscosity in many sulphate-free shampoos builds or falls over one to four weeks as the polymer network settles, so a reading taken on the day of sampling is a poor acceptance criterion.
State a viscosity range rather than a number, name the instrument and conditions — for example "Brookfield RVT, spindle and speed to be stated on the COA, at 25°C, measured at 24 hours and again at 14 days" — and state the pack the product must dispense from. A product that will not leave a lotion pump in winter is a failed product regardless of the number on the certificate.
Foam, clarity and the retail panel
Foam is the property consumers judge in the first ten seconds and the one that falls furthest when sulphates leave. A well-built sulphate-free shampoo foams differently — lower volume, denser bubbles, slower to flash — and a retail panel trained on SLES will call an entirely correct sample "weak."
Give the factory a foam target you can measure: a cylinder shake test or a Ross-Miles-type foam-height test against a named benchmark you send them. "Foam like Brand X" is valid only if you send a bottle of Brand X. And decide early whether your definition allows a sulfonate, because olefin sulfonate is the fastest route to SLES-like foam without a sulphate on the label — and the most likely to draw criticism from a customer who reads INCI lists.
Clarity is the other trade-off. SCI-based systems tend toward opaque or pearl; sarcosinate and taurate systems can be made clear with effort; glucoside-heavy systems are clear but foam poorly. A transparent bottle and a water-clear brief constrain the surfactant choice before anyone opens a formula file.
Compounding time and what it does to lead time
Conventional SLES shampoo is largely cold-process: mix, adjust, thicken with salt, fill. Several sulphate-free surfactants are solids or pastes — SCI needs heat and time to dissolve fully, and undissolved SCI shows up later as grit or haze. Glucosides need pH adjustment; polymeric thickeners need hydration time. Kettle time and cooling time go up, and so does the risk of a defect that only appears after a week in the bottle.
This matters for two lines on your schedule. Custom sampling is not a same-day exercise, because the formulator has to wait for viscosity to settle. And batch time constrains how many batches a plant can turn in a week, which affects whether a stated production window applies to your specific formula.
Yadun Cosmetics, a Guangzhou contract manufacturer whose hair care line covers shampoos, conditioners, hair masks and scalp care in both sulphate-free and conventional systems, publishes standard-formulation sampling of three days, custom development sampling of seven days, and production of 15–30 days after sample approval, from a minimum order of 2,000 units. Read those as stated terms for the general case and confirm them for your surfactant system; the honest answer to "does the seven-day figure hold for my base?" is a formulator's answer, not a sales answer. The general shape of that timeline — sample, revise, approve, then produce — is covered in more depth in the formulation sampling process for cosmetics OEM in China.
Preservation and stability: the questions to ask before the challenge test
Dropping sulphates does not by itself make a shampoo harder to preserve, but sulphate-free formulas are frequently also positioned as "gentle" or "natural," which pushes preservative choice toward sodium benzoate / potassium sorbate at low pH, phenoxyethanol blends or organic-acid systems — each with its own pH window and weaknesses. And several thickeners and glucosides are more nutrient-rich for microbes than an SLES/salt system.
Your brief must ask for a preservative efficacy (challenge) test on the final formula in the final pack, and for an accelerated stability protocol that checks viscosity, pH, colour, odour and phase separation at elevated temperature and through freeze-thaw. Ask specifically for viscosity to be read at each pull, because viscosity drift is the property most likely to fail on a sulphate-free base. Who pays for that testing and which lab issues the report is a separate negotiation; the stability testing and shelf-life guide for cosmetics OEM sets out what a credible protocol looks like. Confirm that the report will be issued in your brand's name, or that you have the right to use it, before you pay for it.
How to write the sulphate-free shampoo brief
Every line below is a field the factory would otherwise have to guess.
- Definition of sulphate-free, written as an exclusion list (SLS, SLES, ALS, ALES, coco-sulfate) with an explicit ruling on sulfonates.
- Positioning constraints: any ingredient list the brand must satisfy (a certification body's standard, a retailer's restricted list, "no PEGs," "no silicones") — these constrain thickener and conditioning choices as much as surfactants.
- Primary surfactant preference if you have one (isethionate, sarcosinate, taurate, glucoside blend), or "factory to propose two systems."
- Foam target as a measurable test against a benchmark you supply.
- Clarity: clear / pearl / opaque, and the pack it must look right in.
- Viscosity range, method and timing (24 h and 14 d), plus the dispensing pack.
- pH window.
- Fragrance load and type, because fragrance oil is a viscosity variable in these systems.
- Preservative constraints and the challenge-test requirement.
- Stability protocol the factory must run before you approve.
- Quantities: pilot fill size, then production quantity, so the factory can confirm whether the base changes between kettle sizes.
- Deliverables with the sample: full INCI with percentages or ranges, surfactant activity levels, a raw-material supplier list for the surfactants, and the viscosity/pH readings on the COA.
Item 12 is where OEM and ODM diverge. On an OEM brief you supply the formula. On an ODM brief, where the factory supplies an existing house base for you to brand, you need the full INCI before you can make the sulphate-free claim at all, and you need to know whether the base is exclusive or shared. A wider template for this kind of specification is set out in the guide to writing a product spec sheet for a Chinese factory.
Common questions
Is a sulphate-free shampoo automatically milder?
Not automatically. Mildness depends on the whole system — surfactant type, total load, pH, amphoterics and conditioning agents. A poorly balanced sulphate-free blend at high load can be less gentle than a well-built SLES/CAPB formula. Do not write mildness claims into the brief unless you intend to substantiate them with your own testing.
Why did the sample thicken in the bottle two weeks after it arrived?
Polymeric and associative thickeners take time to reach their final network structure. This is expected, and it is why the brief should specify a 14-day viscosity reading. If the factory measured only at 24 hours, the acceptance reading and the retail reading are different products.
Does the MOQ change for a sulphate-free base?
There is no chemical reason it should, but ask. Some surfactant raw materials are bought in drum or bag quantities that set a practical minimum batch for a custom base, particularly amino-acid surfactants the plant does not otherwise stock. Whether a 2,000-unit fill matches the minimum kettle for your system belongs in the quote.
What to ask the supplier next
Before you approve a sulphate-free shampoo sample, get written answers to these:
- Which surfactant system is the sample built on, and at what active matter? You need this to defend the claim and compare quotes.
- Do you hold a house sulphate-free base for ODM, and is it exclusive or shared? If shared, ask whether it can be modified for you.
- Where are the surfactants sourced, and what incoming screening is done? For ethoxylated materials, ask whether supplier certificates cover residual 1,4-dioxane and are retained by lot.
- What is the viscosity at 24 hours and 14 days, on which instrument, at what temperature? Get both readings on the COA.
- What preservative system is used, and has a challenge test been run on this exact formula in this pack? Ask for the report and whose name it is in.
- What is the kettle batch time for this base, and does the stated production window apply to it?
- Does the 2,000-unit MOQ apply per formula or per finished SKU, and what is the minimum batch for this specific base?
Yadun Cosmetics is one example of the profile to look for — a Baiyun District plant running both sulphate-free and conventional hair care systems, in a district where raw materials, packaging and testing labs sit within a short radius, quoting from 2,000 units. Those are company-stated terms. Confirm every one in writing against your specific formula, and read the factory profile with the checklist above open beside it.
